Why 2 Great Clients Can Pay You More Than 50 Average Ones

Two profit share clients went from under $100k a month to $1M a month. The math on why 2 great clients beat 50 average ones, and how I structure those deals.

For years I thought more clients meant more money. And it does, up to a point. Then it means more staff, more complaints, more refunds and way more stuff that can go wrong.

What changed my business was two clients. Not two hundred. Two. I want to walk you through what happened with them, because it’s the clearest way I know to show why I run things the way I do now.

Quick answer: Can a few great profit share clients pay more than dozens of flat fee clients?

Yes. Two of my profit share clients went from about $75,000 and $100,000 a month to $1M a month. At a 50% margin and a 20% share, that is about $100,000 a month each, or $200,000 from two clients. Matching that on flat fees would take about 50 clients paying $4,000 a month.

  • One client hit $1M a month in 60 days; the other took about 12 months.
  • Two clients at $1M a month, 50% margin and a 20% share pay about $200,000 a month combined.
  • The old model sold $16,000 four month packages and peaked at about 100 new clients a month.
  • On smaller deals I use a $5,000 monthly floor plus a one time $5,000 setup fee.
  • If the floor kicks in twice, either side can end the deal.

Two clients, two very different timelines

One came to us doing about $75,000 a month. The other was doing about $100,000 a month. Both are profit share partners, which means I get paid on what they make, not a flat fee.

The first one hit $1M a month in 60 days, which was crazy. The second one took about 12 months to get there. Different speed, same destination.

Now just do some quick math. Let’s say each of them is at a million a month with about a 50% margin, so $500,000 in profit, and I take 20%. That’s $100,000 a month from each one, $200,000 a month from two clients. To match that the old way I’d need about 50 clients paying me $4,000 a month, plus the team to serve all of them.

What did the old way look like?

The old model sold a $16,000 package for 4 months, and about 30% of people upgraded to a $48,000 package for 12 months. At our peak we were bringing in around 100 clients a month like that.

It worked, I’m not going to pretend it didn’t. But it took a ton of ad spend and a ton of staff. Each account manager handled about 50 clients, and once they went much past that, the quality dropped hard. And a lot of those clients were beginners. Nothing against beginners, but coaching a kid in kindergarten to play basketball is a very different job than coaching LeBron.

Why did these two clients work?

I look for two things now. Number one is a very good CEO. If the person running the company is great, everything I do lands faster. Number two is a very good offer, ideally one without a ton of competition. A fitness offer is a red ocean. Something like helping people get a green card or get into an Ivy League school is way easier to grow because fewer people are fighting for the same buyer.

Both of those clients had both things. So instead of dragging someone from zero, I was just pouring gas on something that already worked.

The team behind them is small too. I’m the strategist on the bigger accounts, and under me there’s a copywriter, a project manager and a media buyer. The project manager runs the plan, the copywriter writes the emails and funnel scripts, and the media buyer runs the ads. With a team that small it’s way easier to see when somebody isn’t doing their job.

How do I protect myself on smaller deals?

Not everyone who wants a profit share is doing $100,000 a month. For those people I set a $5,000 floor. If my share comes in under that, they pay the difference. Usually there’s a one time $5,000 setup fee, and if the floor kicks in twice, either side can walk.

The reason is simple. It’s not worth taking someone on for less than about 3 months, because we do a bunch of work up front. For someone already doing $100,000 a month, the floor never even matters since my share is usually 20% to 40% and that’s way above $5,000.

And these deals run 2 years, not 4 months. A client paying you $100,000 a month for 2 years is worth $2.4M. That’s a very different business than replacing your whole client list every few months.

What I’d tell you to do with this

You don’t need to switch to profit share tomorrow. But I’d look hard at who you’re working with. If most of your problems come from clients who aren’t ready, the fix probably isn’t more clients. It’s better ones, and a smaller team that’s good enough to serve them.

I walked through the whole model on a whiteboard, including the staffing at every stage from $0 to $1M a month, in the full breakdown on tannerchidester.com.

Frequently asked questions

How does a profit share consulting deal compare to a flat fee retainer?

With profit share, I get paid on what the client makes, not a fixed fee. A client at $1M a month with a 50% margin makes $500,000 profit. At a 20% share, that is $100,000 a month to me. To match two clients like that on flat fees, I would need about 50 clients paying $4,000 a month, plus the team to serve them.

What did the old high volume consulting package model look like?

We sold a $16,000 package for 4 months, and about 30% upgraded to $48,000 for 12 months. At the peak we brought in about 100 new clients a month. That needed heavy ad spend, lots of staff and account managers holding about 50 clients each. Quality dropped hard past that, and beginners were harder to serve.

How do I protect myself on smaller profit share deals?

I set a $5,000 monthly floor. If my share comes in under that, the client pays the difference. I also charge a one time $5,000 setup fee because the upfront work is heavy. If the floor kicks in twice, either side can end the deal. It is not worth taking on for less than about 3 months.

What makes a client a good fit for a profit share partnership?

A strong CEO and an offer that is not in a crowded market. Those two things are why my best two clients scaled. For clients around $100K a month, the share is usually 20% to 40%, and deals run about 2 years, not 4 months. At $100,000 a month for 2 years, one client is worth $2.4M.

Want to know what’s capping your business right now? Take my free 90 Day Ceiling Plan. Answer 18 questions and get a written plan, built on your own numbers, that names the one thing holding you back and what to fix first.

Written by Tanner Chidester, founder and CEO of Elite CEOs. He has done over $150M in sales, worked with 50,000+ clients, and hosts the Infinite Income Podcast.

Share this post
Recent News

I hope you enjoy reading this blog post.

If you want my team at EliteCeos to help you get more traffic, just book a call.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *